So it got me to thinking, what other secular songs could be sang to Jesus: Here are my top 5 (and 2 from the comments). If you have suggestions, I'll edit to get to a top 10.
7. Love - Musiq Soulchild
6. Everything to me - Monica
5. Dangerously in Love - Beyonce
4. Flaws and All - Beyonce
3. He Loves Me (actually Jill said in an interview that when she first wrote this song it was about God, then she changed it to be about romantic love on the album)
2. For Real - Amel Larrieux
1. Everything - Mary J. Blige